10 Toasted Sandwich Recipes You Will Absolutely Love

We love toasted sandwiches here at Kitchen Authority so choosing the best toasted sandwich recipes was challenging but delicious!

We’ve reviewed a ton of sandwich makers that can help you in your pursuit of the perfect toasted sandwich or panini.

Here’s what in our opinion are the top 10 toasted sandwiches ideas. Enjoy!

Chicken Fajita Toasted Sandwich | It Shouldn’t Work, But It Does

The humble toasted sandwich is one of the most adaptable sandwiches on earth.

There are almost an unlimited number of options when it comes to filling two slices of bread and throwing it all in a sandwich maker.

That’s not to say, however, that all of those options pay off and I was pretty skeptical about a chicken fajita sandwich.

Until I tried it. It was lovely!

What’s your favorite strange food combination?

I think the choice of bread for this recipe is important and I’ve written about the best breads for sandwiches on the blog.

Keto Cauliflower Grilled Cheese Sandwich | The No Bread Toastie!

If you’re trying to watch your waistline but you really want a toasted sandwich then don’t despair!

The truth is that cauliflower isn’t just good for pizza bases in keto-land and, in fact, it does a great job as a bread substitute in an actual toasted sandwich.

No, it’s not my first choice for taste but considering this is nearly all cauliflower – it tastes pretty darn good!

Do you have any other Keto tips you could share?

The Mumbai Chocolate Toasted Sandwich | So Wrong But So Tasty

I know that Nutella’s a thing and that people do put chocolate sauces on bread all the time but there’s something in my traditional make up that says that a chocolate sandwich toastie is all kinds of wrong.

Fortunately, I managed to keep my inner nag at bay and try the Mumbai Chocolate Sandwich and despite my instincts, it’s really yummy!

What other sweet – savory combos do you love?

Bombay Masala Toasted Sandwiches | India Loves To Be Creative

Curried toasted sandwiches anyone?

Well, I don’t mind if I do.

Indian cuisine is endlessly varied and it often surprise me just how creative it can be with ingredients that aren’t so “traditional”. You know, like toasted bread.

This Bombay Masala Toast recipe is commonly seen on Indian streets and it’s scrumptious!

Do you have any unusual sandwich fillings that you love?

The Cheeseburger In A Sandwich Press | Making The Most Out Of Your Devices

I love toasted sandwiches. We’ve got a ton of sandwich makers at home that we’ve tried for Kitchen Authority and nobody in my family is complaining.

So, I was extra-excited to learn that it’s perfectly possible to cook a cheeseburger in a sandwich press. Who doesn’t want to get more out of their kitchen devices?

Check it out!

What else do you make in your sandwich press?

Korean Street Toast | Something Different To Snack On

When you think toast, you probably don’t think “Korea” automatically.

That’s a shame as Seonkyoung Longest’s recipe for Korean Street Toast is easily one of the tastiest treats of the year and it may be one of the healthiest sandwich recipes I’ve featured recently too.

I make mine in a sandwich maker and it works great!

Are you going to try this?

The Best Grilled Ham And Cheese Sandwich Ever?

I am going to level with you. Since I discovered the sandwich toaster, I’ve stopped making grilled cheese on the stove top.

I don’t see the point when you can do the same thing without the mess and the sandwiches are neater too.

However, I’ll give Sam the Cooking Guy credit where credit’s due – this is a sensational ham and cheese grilled sandwich.

What do you think? Do you know a better recipe?

Bread Pizza Sandwiches | An Indian Twist On Italian Food

This is one of India Eats all-time most popular recipes with over 11 million people tuning into it.

The idea is simple, to create a pizza like feel but without the hassle of pizza dough. In essence, pizza sandwiches.

I like to take this process one step further by making them into “calzones” and putting an extra slice of bread on top and cooking them in the sandwich toaster.

What’s your favorite “cheat” recipe?

Ainsley Harriott’s Best Jamaican Toasted Sandwich Recipe | Awesomely Authentic And So Tasty!

Ainsley Harriott is a very well-known British chef whose roots are in Jamaica.

Here he shares one of his all-time favorite recipes for a Jamaican toasted sandwich.

This is also one of my all-time faves. It’s so easy to make, it tastes great and makes you feel wonderful about food.

What other Jamaican recipes do you know of?

Leave a comment and let us know what you think!

If you want to know more about toasted sandwiches then check out the: Kitchen Authority Complete Guide to Sandwich Makers.